Sunday, January 27, 2008

对,还是错?

今天的PS(Professional Studies)课结束前,讲师要我们针对一个案例发表意见。

案例的状况是。。。
(以下为案例原文)

In Europe, a woman was near death from a special kind of cancer.
There was one drug that the doctors thought might save her. It was a form of radium that a druggist in the same town had recently discovered.
The drug was expensive to make, but the druggist was charging 10 times what the drug cost him to make. He paid $200 for the radium and charged $2000for a small dose of the drug.
The sick women’s husband, Heniz, went to everyone he known to b
orrow money, but he could only get together about $1000, which is half of what it cost. He told druggist that his wife was dying and asked him to sell it cheaper or let him pay later.
But the druggist said: “No, I discovered the drug and I’m going to make money from it.”
So, Heniz got desperate and broke into man’s store to steal the drug for his wife.
Should the husband have done that?

以下为译文:
案例的实况是有个女子得了癌症。

医生认为有种药能够对她的病情有所帮助。

那药物的制作费用很高,而药商要用比原价多十倍的价钱售出。

制作药物的原料需
$200,而药商决定以一剂$2000的价钱出售。
但是,那女子的丈夫却只能够筹到
$1000,虽然他已经尽力了。
于是,那丈夫跟药商求情说他的妻子已在垂死边缘了,希望能降低药价或者稍后才还那笔钱。

但是,药商却说:“不行,这药物是我发现的,我要用这药物来赚钱的。”

最后,那丈夫在情急之下到药商那儿偷了那药物给他的妻子。

你觉得丈夫应该这样做吗?

如果你是案例里的丈夫,你又会怎做呢?
这案例跟数学题或科学题完全不同,没有任何标准的答案。
如果以法律的角度来看,或许你就会认为那丈夫做错了。
但,如果以人情道义来说的话,你或许就会支持那丈夫的举动了吧。
如果你是案例里的妻子,你又会怎样看待呢。。。

也许在现实生活中,很多事情也是没有所谓的对或错,只是在于您用什么角度来看待吧。。。

???

7 comments:

MedicBoyz said...

就象你说的,看自己从什么角度看。
我觉得错的应该是丈夫吧。
因为偷窃是有罪的,无论你有什么原因。

药商选择不卖药,我们只能怪他没良心,但不能说他错。
这种情况让人很无奈...

没人妖部落格格@"勤"QIN said...

不是每一人多那么的顺利.每一个事情都要以多角度去看和想,即使它是多么的伤你。虽然雨天过后的彩虹并非你想象的完美但至少用另外的角度去看和想,心情也会便得开心,开朗^^是这样吗?^^

Yimino said...

MedicBoyz,
是啊,不同的人对于不同的事物有不同的诠释方法,想法与观点。。。
也许有些事物会让人觉得无奈,也让人奈何不了吧。。。


没人妖部落格格@"勤"QIN,
是有道理,凡事都要往好处想。。。
不过,我觉得雨天过后的彩虹并没有不完美啊。。。哈:)

丽庭 said...

事情真的只能看你从哪个方向哪个角度去观察,去感受文中人物的心情..

Yimino said...

丽庭,
是啊。。。
每个人的观点都不同。。。
心中所持着的那个秤也不同。。。

小丑 said...

Sorry ya I couldn't be able to answer you in Chinese...but I think English will do too.

Here come to my answer.Perhaps, the story you sharing with us above was one of my tutorial question during the subject of MEDIA ETHICS in my degree, that is why I felt it familiar when I 1st reading it.

If you were the person with the characteristic that care about the consequences, then rescue your wife's life is the 1st priority than nothing else.

If you were the one who stictly obey to the law, then the breaking in would not be your choice and stealing others' property would not be fair to the victim too.

But things out there would always come with the alternatives. You can't just stand there for doing nothing. However, you also can't go and steal the drug as this action would put you into jail. The alternative ways could be...write the letter to some charity based organisations and tell them the situation you are facing and ask them to raise the fund for you like what the most newspaper now doing (i suggest).

HAha...seemed like I've commented too much d...haha.Watever, thank you for visiting my blog yo.

I am small-ugly.

Yimino said...

小丑,
thanks 4 sharing yr opinion...its a good suggestion...